• Home
  • Lawmakers hear arguments for changing Kansas' court selection process at legislative retreat

Lawmakers hear arguments for changing Kansas' court selection process at legislative retreat

Source: 
The Wichita Eagle
Author: 
Brent D. Wistrom
Date: 
Saturday, December 8, 2012

Conservative lawmakers heard several options Saturday for changing how Kansas’ appellate and Supreme Court judges are selected in a discussion that may foreshadow a fierce debate in the upcoming legislative session.

Stephen Ware, a law professor at the University of Kansas, said Kansas’ judicial selection system is unusual and “undemocratic” in how it chooses its nominating commission.

Kansans elect a governor and the governor selects four members of the commission. But five of the members are elected by 10,000 or so members of the Kansas Bar Association.

Ware said Kansas is alone in giving the bar control of the majority of the commission. He said that violates the one-person, one-vote foundation of democracy by giving lawyers too much control in selecting judges via their private elections.

“It’s very political, but it’s out of the sunshine,” Ware said at a meeting of mostly conservative Republicans hosted by the nonprofit Kansas Legislative Education and Research group in Topeka. “Do you want your politics out in the open or do you want your politics behind closed doors?”

He said the state could reduce the number of commission members selected by the bar or the state could add Senate confirmation to provide more accountability.

Ware said he favors a third option — eliminating the commission and having the governor select judges with confirmation votes by the Senate.

Ware said some argue that once a judge is on the court, voters can kick them off in retention votes. But no judge has ever lost a retention election in Kansas, he said.

Why KU
  • Top 25 among public law schools — Business Insider
  • KU’s Project for Innocence: 2 wrongfully convicted citizens serving life sentences freed in 2015
  • 7,700+ alumni in all 50 states, D.C., 3 U.S. territories, and 20 foreign countries
  • 91 percent overall employment rate for Class of 2015 – top 23.3 percent nationally
  • 23rd in the nation for most-improved employment rates
  • One-third of full-time faculty have written casebooks and treatises
  • 25th nationwide for lowest debt at graduation
  • 21st: “Best Schools for Practical Training”
  • 77 percent of upper-level law classes have 25 or fewer students
  • National Champions: 2016 National Native American Law Students Association Moot Court Competition
  • #19 moot court program in the nation
  • #17 “best value” law school in the nation — National Jurist Magazine