• Home
  • Supreme Court: US genes patent decision may depend on strands in Myriad argument

Supreme Court: US genes patent decision may depend on strands in Myriad argument

Source: 
Financial Times
Author: 
Stephanie Kirchgaessner
Date: 
Tuesday, May 28, 2013

In June, the Supreme Court will release its decision on whether genes may be patented, which will have a far-reaching impact on the biotechnology industry. A Financial Times article on the subject quoted Andrew Torrance, professor of law.

Kirchgaessner wrote:

"It was obvious from the questions they asked and analogies that they dreamt up that the nine US Supreme Court justices hearing one of the most important and complex patent cases in a decade were not wholly comfortable with the subject at hand.

The question before them – whether human genes could be patented – seems straightforward on the surface. Yet as the arguments turned to talk of recombinant DNA and whether isolated DNA fragments were found in nature or were a product of man, the judges quickly turned to quizzing attorneys with more accessible analogies involving baseball bats and chocolate chip cookies.

...

Scientific and legal experts are trying to gauge just how disruptive the case may be. Before it was heard, one patent expert predicted the results could be disastrous.

“Synthetic DNA sequences, designed by humans, may be excluded from this prohibition but the invalidation of patents claiming human genes will wipe out vast amounts of private investment, and be a body blow to the biotechnology industry,” says Andrew Torrance, professor at the University of Kansas law school."

FULL STORY (requires subscription)

Why KU
  • One-third of full-time faculty have written casebooks used at U.S. law schools
  • 2 KU law faculty were U.S. Supreme Court clerks
  • KU’s Project for Innocence: 33 conviction reversals since 2009
  • 7,300+ alumni live in all 50 states and 18 foreign countries
  • Routinely ranked a “best value” law school
  • 12 interdisciplinary joint degrees
  • 26th nationwide for lowest debt at graduation. — U.S. News & World Report
  • 70 percent of upper-level law classes have 25 or fewer students
  • Nearly 800 employment interviews at law school, 2012-13
  • Top 25% for number of 2013 grads hired by the nation’s largest law firms